I brought this from I believe CVS a while ago and I was so excited and then so disappointed! I wanted the long, sleek, black beautiful lashes it promised but all I ended up with was a mess. It made my lashes to wet, Didn't curl or leave my lashes voluminous it just kind of left them there hanging no matter how many times I used my curler. It just wasn't good. I love the brand and have had tons of Maybelline products and I tend to love them but this was a epic fail.