The only reason I bought this pencil It’s because I ran out of my tart shake or we don’t need eyeliner pencil and besides Marc Jacobs which is a ridiculous $25 an eyeliner and comes with much less product I couldn’t find any other high and nude eyeliners and I didn’t have time to go drive to the altar which is either 30 to 45 minutes away depending on which location you go to and I didn’t have time to wait for to get online while I ordered it so I ordered it but in the meantime I bought this pencil as a fill-in because yet again it was the only drugstore new pencil that I could find in the store I really hate to say that you get what you pay for in the situation the tart eyeliner fills in my waterline and you can tell it’s there it makes my eyes pop open and it looks good thisLooks like it rubs off with the pencil looks like it doesn’t add any color and it’s very frustrating looks nothing like the tart and I wholeheartedly believe with make up in general you get what you pay for except with maybe a few exceptions

This is better than other eyeliners for the waterline, but still not great. I bought it to give a hint of purple on my waterline to bring out my blue eyes. But it only really appears purple with a lot on, which is not an everyday look. It also doesn’t stay on my waterline for more than about 2 hours. I’ve even tried setting it with purple eyeshadow and while it does look more purple, it still doesn’t stay all day. I like it but probably won’t buy it again.

I love this white eyeliner! I use it for two primary purposes. First, I use it in the corner of my eyes to make my eyes pop. Secondly I use it above my Cupid’s bow to make my lips appear more defined. This eyeliner is highly bendable. It also has a decent pigment. It is definitely a bargain for the price. I would recommend this eyeliner in any color for people looking for a liner to create a smudged, Smokey eye look.

I literally bought this today at Ulta, I was looking at the L'Oréal one but I got this instead and I'm wearing it now. So far so good it says it's waterproof and it's been holding up on my waterline, I just thought that it would be a flat nude color and it's actually kind of metalic at first I was surprised but it's not really bad.

This eyeliner blends very easily and smudges great to create smokey eye looks. I have also used it to create a wing however I did use my brush to get the wing nice and sharp. It’s formula is super creamy but once it’s dry it won’t budge. I have only tried the toffee colored one but I might go and try others because I like it so much.

This is my waterline eyeliner of choice. I honestly do not know why more people do not talk about this. When I say it stays put, it stays put until I take my makeup off. The first time I used this was for a wedding I went to, I applied my makeup in the morning, and after a long night of dancing and drinks it was still EXACTLY the way I applied it hours prior.
The only downside to this eyeliner is that it can rub onto contact lenses and smear on them, it can be rubbed off with moderate pressure. I apply it with a brush now to eliminate this problem.
I plan to purchase more colors of this, I love a fun waterline and this is an affordable and honestly perfect way to achieve the look.

I loveeee this product. 
Its long lasting and finshing is amazing.
I love this top most brand.
This  is one of my favorites brands and with reasonable price.
I bought this from walmart store and it is also available in other stores like Fred Meyer,target,walgreens many.......
It gives soft texture on skin. 
I would definitely recommend this product and brand too.
Its better to search for offers before buying.
Have different shades of color for different skin tones.
I like to visit above stores only to buy this and find offers.
It gives fantastic look for party and for simple makeup also.
I am kinda shopholic ;) so love to buy and try different products ,brands and shades.
It would be too nice if there are some small samples to try before we buy.
Shade is just awesome on my skin and hope for others too.
It has matte texture.
I would definitely buy More n more n more...
I love trying new products and samples tooooooo.
Its bestiest best product I have ever used...

I really like this drug store eyeliner. I have mono lids so sometimes my eyes crease in the weirdest spots BUT this eyeliner doesn’t smudge and is easy to apply and clean up too. I like the affordability of this product and honestly, it is better than my BB eyeliner (BobbiBrown). 

This is the first gel pencil I have found that lasts all day, and didn't cost me a fortune! No smudges, no goopy corners, no clumps -- just precision, definition and drama, for hours! It is super easy to use, and adds instant color like a liquid. I have found my new drug store go-to eyeliner!

I purchased this liner and I was pretty disappointed. It was so soft that I could even get a straight line without it smudging. I returned this to the store because I knew I wasn't going to use it again. Maybe they made the liner So It blends easily, but this was too easily smudged.