"This is a great color and it doesn't smudge all over your eyes, it stays in place. I love the Maybelline expert wear pencils and especially in the brownish black." in 112 reviews

1965 reviews

Sarah H.

Lake St Louis , MO

259 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3

March 21, 2018, 7:50 p.m.

This is my go-to drugstore eyeliner. I love that it is available at every local drugstore. The price cannot be beat for this product. It provides long lasting color that glides on your eyelids. Stays in place once applied and great product. I also love that it comes in a lime green package, it can’t get lost in my purse or makeup bag.

Skin Tone:

Neutral

Eyes:

Blue

Lashes:

Full

Like This?

Kaitlin D.

Boston

107 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2

May 1, 2018, 9:11 a.m.

This eyeliner is okay to me. If I’m using a drugstore brand, this is what I’ll grab since it’s easy to use, but if I want something more durable that will last me longer, then I’ll opt for something that is higher brand. But this does the trick if you need some touch ups and you can carry this in your purse.

Skin Tone:

Medium

Eyes:

Brown

Lashes:

Long

Like This?

Heather B.

Chicopee , MA

129 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2

March 9, 2018, 12:37 a.m.

This is one of my go to eyeliner products but I think that it could be much better in the area of rubbing or smudging off. I love that it glides on very smoothly and gives a crisp line but it is definitely not something to use if you were trying to do any cat eyes or anything that you want to ultra fine line for

Skin Tone:

Fair

Eyes:

Green

Lashes:

FullLong

Like This?

Dawna G.

Jemison

189 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2

March 22, 2018, 3:35 p.m.

If I clicked on the right product, I liked this eye liner. It went on smooth and stayed on till I took it off. Had great pigmentation and didn't irritate my eyes. I would buy this again and I would recommend it to my friends. It's affordable and that's a huge plus for me.

Skin Tone:

Olive

Eyes:

Hazel

Lashes:

ThinShortStraight

Like This?

Taylor B.

Pell City, AL

109 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2

April 5, 2018, 12:45 p.m.

This is definitely my go to eyeliner and it lasts me a while. I bought this at Walmart and the price was great. I have been using this eyeliner for years. It is so easy to put on unlike most other eyeliners. I will definitely keep buying this and definitely will recommend to other users.

Skin Tone:

Fair

Eyes:

Hazel

Lashes:

Long

Like This?

Connie S.

2 reviews

May 14, 2018, 5:11 p.m.

i really have use you an eyebrow pencil because from being alot younger i over tweezed so bad that now my brows do not grow in certain places so now i have to color in a bit with some brown brow pencil....really enjoy this product..my brows thank u

Skin Tone:

Neutral

Eyes:

Brown

Lashes:

Thin

Like This?

Maha S.

Princeton, TX

24 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1

March 8, 2018, 10:03 p.m.

This is my everyday liner. I have been using it for such a long time. It’s so creamy and perfect for the waterline. It glides smoothly and is such a great value. It is not expensive and it works just as great as a high end eyeliner. It is amazing.

Skin Tone:

Medium

Eyes:

Brown

Lashes:

Full

Like This?

N I E M A N 🌵.

Seattle, WA

24 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1

Sept. 11, 2017, 1:55 p.m.

LOVE LOVE LOVE. Have never loved a brow product more. Perfect cool toned taupe for my blonde hair that fluctuates from lighter to darker shades throughout the year. Consistency makes it easy to apply, it's a creamy pencil. So inexpensive and comes in a two pack--I think it's only $4. No other brow product, pomade, pencil, etc. compares. I don't know why more people don't try this, it's such an underrated product.

Skin Tone:

Neutral

Eyes:

Blue

Lashes:

ThinCurled

Like This?

Kandice H.

19 reviews

May 9, 2018, 10:29 a.m.

I really like this eyeliner but I don’t care for the fact that it has to be sharpened. It’s a good price though. I would buy it again if it was in a plastic stick. Definitely recommend for someone on a budget.

Like This?

✨Sandra✨ E.

55 reviews

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1

May 4, 2018, 4:57 p.m.

So I always swap between this and covergirl because they are the only two I found that are really long lasting wear, waterproof and for sensitive eyes. I use their onyx black and love the deepness of the Black.

Skin Tone:

Golden

Eyes:

Brown

Lashes:

ThinLongStraight

Like This?

12 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ...Next >

Q & A

chasity f.

7 reviews

2 years, 10 months ago

Is this pencil useful as a eye liner and eye brow liner or should it only be use on one or the other?

Like This?

Answer This

Belle J.

Lamoni, IA

1 year, 10 months ago

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3

Most definitely! I've used this for both for many years. Stays on all day too!

See All (6) Answers

Taylor K.

Bellville, Oh

89 reviews

3 years, 4 months ago

Does it smudge during the day or does it stay in place throughout the day?

Like This?

Answer This

McKenzie M.

Payson, UT

3 years ago

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3

Stays just fine for me! Especially when I use a brow gel or setting wax.

See All (4) Answers

Claire W.

6 reviews

2 years, 3 months ago

I have always used the Maybelline master precise liquid pen eyeliner and I love it a lot. I have never used this and I have always wanted to try it but I don't really know the difference. Is it basically the same idea?

Like This?

Answer This

Refat Z.

Queens Vlg, NY

2 years, 3 months ago

Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3

This is great for the under eye well that's what I use it for

See All (2) Answers

Alaina A.

Blue Springs, MO

28 reviews

4 years, 8 months ago