Mary Jane Candies uploaded by isis f.Mary Jane Candies uploaded by Ashley W.Mary Jane Candies uploaded by Lakeisha C.
Mary Jane Candies

Mary Jane Candies


4.4 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars64%
  • 4 Stars24%
  • 3 Stars6%
  • 2 Stars2%
  • 1 Star3%


Mary Jane®  Peanut butter and molasses chewy candy. The great tasting mary janes you remember when you were growing up. 240 Count Tub The History: In 1884, Charles H. Miller and his three sons founded a small business manufacturing and selling homemade candy.  The building where they began making their candy had a notable past -- it was the Paul Revere House in Boston s Faneuil Hall/North End area.  After their father s death, the Miller boys split the responsibilities of the family business.  Charles N. Miller took charge of the manufacturing and wholesale operations while his brothers ran the retail store.  In 1914, after a fairly successful business was established and the Charles N. Miller Company was one of some reputation, they began manufacturing Mary Janes.  The molasses and peanut butter candy was named for their favorite aunt, Mary see more...

Top Questions See all 3 Q&A

Mary Jane Candies
Mary Jane Candies
Reviews (120)
Q&A (2)
Media (3)
Leave a Review
  • "These come in second to bit-o-honey, which is not a peanut butter flavor but very similar in shape and texture. " in 11 reviews
  • "These are my moms favorite they are pretty good, good flavor although they do get stuck in your teeth" in 11 reviews
  • "They are very chewy and take a while to eat but they taste sooo good." in 5 reviews
  • "These bring back so many childhood memories from the penny candy store!" in 3 reviews
  • "I love the peanut butter flavor and that smooth creamy taste that you can't stop eating." in 3 reviews
Stephanie H.
Wellsville, NY
198 reviews
These are one if my mama's favorite candy. They have a nice sweet peanut butter flavor and almost remind me of peanut butter taffy that you would buy from a tasty stand at a county fair. Saying they're chewy us an understatement.. 😂😂 they take forever to eat.
Carmen A.
Kissimmee, FL
356 reviews
Oooohhhh this is an oldie but goodie!!! This brings me way way back!! So so delicious!! I didn't even mind having them stuck all over my teeth cause they were so so good!!!!
isis f.
El Cajon, CA
16 reviews
The iconic Mary Jane!! If you love reese peanut butter cups, this is the candy for you to snack on! This candy is very very chewy like extra chewy taffy, so I would not recommend for little kids. Overall it's DELISH, has a strong peanut butter flavor!
318 reviews
These are my mom's favorite candies. I like them a lot, but they are so chewy and it takes so long to get this out of your teeth once you're done. But the struggle is worth it, because these are some freaking delicious treats. Only downside is that I always have a hard time finding them in the big containers
Brandi P.
Scottsburg, IN
6 reviews
These are my favorite candies of all times. I love when halloween comes because you can buy them everywhere and my kids get a bunch when we go trick or treating!
Gladys R.
Georgetown, SC
106 reviews
I love Mary Jane's and it's probally because its candy that we grew up on. They are hard to find these days unless you vist a store that carries a lot of the old days candies. I love the hard but chewy texture and the flavor is really nice. I really enjoy the peanut pieces that are present at the end. I'll take this chewy candy any day of the week and can eat a whole bag of them. I can usually find these at the 5 below store.
Lakeisha C.
Pearcy, AR
5 reviews
My dad loved this candy. It was the least liked among my siblings so he would get it all. I would usually try a piece only after my other candy was gone LOL It is a Halloween favorite and I don't think i would feel the same if it wasn't at least a piece in the candy bucket on Halloween night!
Tiffany F.
Hamilton, OH
190 reviews
I absolutely love these little candies. If you love peanut butter, you should definitely try these. They are soft, chewy, and full of peanut butter flavor. I will warn you that they will get stuck in your teeth which is why I prefer to pull off a piece and eat it that way instead of sticking the whole thing in my mouth at once. I highly recommend these.
Sophia A.
Gaffney, SC
63 reviews
My grandmother would love to try to shove these down out throats. As a kid she loved them, but as for my brothers and I... WE HATED THEM. I love peanut butter but the texture and taste of this product ruined peanut butter for me. It is also terrible for your teeth because it gets stuck in them. Welcome to cavity city and it wasn't even worth it.
Abby W.
Unionville, MI
211 reviews
Sweet Tooth Expert Level 2
My all time favorite fall treat! The yummy peanut butter core meshes perfectly with the taffy creating an ooey gooey goodness in your mouth. I love how easy to find and affordable Mary Janes are. Old fashioned candies are the best kind of candies!
Holly D.
San Antonio, TX
131 reviews
never tried these do they sell in TX?
Rhiannon V.
271 reviews
Sweet Tooth Expert Level 2
Pros and cons? Worth trying?

Sign up to join our community!

Influenster Cashback
We recorded your visit.
Mary Jane Candies

was opened in another window. If you made a purchase Cash Back will be automatically added to your Ebates account tomorrow.

Please confirm your email.
If you have an existing Ebates account, make sure to enter your Ebates email

6 characters minimum. Password must consist of letters, at least 1 number and 1 special character.