Usually store brand products are ones I buy for these "staple" items but I was not impressed with the market pantry peanut butter. Super greasy. Not enough peanut flavor. Would be alright if you hadn't already tried JIF or Skippy. Sorry target...Market Pantry peanut butter is a miss.
Can't go wrong with peanut butter. Market pantry has really good peanut butter for pretty cheap. It is pretty yummy, especially on toast. I don't think it's good for you, cause I'm pretty sure they add sugar. But I would recommend it if you're on a budget and want yummy peanut butter.
It's just a little on the grainy side for my particular tastes as a spread, but given it's less-sweet flavor, I do still like it, if it's on sale. I also like to use it for baking, for which it works really well.