I wanted to love this but it smudged easily on my waterline and for tightlining. I don’t have especially oily lids or watery eyes but this didn’t work for me. It also dried out pretty fast with the lid secured on.

I like how you get a pot/gel liner in a pencil its so convenient and easy to use I really enjoy this eyeliner its also super creamy glides right on. Its so versatile perfect for different looks.

They are nice and easy to use. I have it in black and a glittery one. I use it to make my eyes smokey as it is not super dark. I tried using it on the waterline but it doesn’t really work there. It’s a nice product but not a wow.