My dogs love this toy! We bought a pink medium sized one and a small purple sized one. Decided to get two because they were marked half the price at our local store and anything that's non rubber and is cloth material will be shredded in no time. The mess-- I had enough of cleaning and picking up wet soppy stuffings! Especially when they tried eating stuffed toys and eventually choking up a storm. If you don't want to experience this, just buy this toy. Plus-- it's easy to hold on to if you want to play with your dogs AND it's easy to clean!