Woah there, it looks like your browser is out of date.

To get the best experience, please update your browser.

MAC False Lashes Mascara

BY MAC COSMETICS

4.2 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars53%
  • 4 Stars29%
  • 3 Stars11%
  • 2 Stars5%
  • 1 Star3%
4.24 / 5 based on 228 Reviews

Top Questions See all 25 Q&A

  • Is this worth the splurge?3 Answers
  • I love this mascara for the density it gives the lashes, but I find...1 Answers
  • Is this a great product to use ? 1 Answers
MAC False Lashes Mascara
MAC False Lashes Mascara
Reviews (228)
Q&A (25)
Media (22)
Leave a Review
Rita W.
Rita W.
New York, NY
124 reviews
I purchased this MAC False Lashes waterproof mascara in "Stay Black" color at the MAC counter at Saks. It was difficult to decide how many stars to give this mascara, as I would like to give a 3.5 instead of a 3 or a 4, but since that's not an option, its a bit closer to 4 than 3, so I went with a 4 rating.

Why did I give this mascara a 4? Well, because the mascara bills itself as a waterproof mascara that will not smear or run, and it accomplishes that amazingly well. Once I apply this mascara, it does not run, it does not smear, and it won't even come off if I'm caught in a rainstorm. So on that characteristic, it is superior. It does not do much in terms of volumizing my lashes, however, and I wouldn't say my eyelashes appear so lush/long that they appear false. This mascara gives a good, bold, black color to my lashes, and enhances them moderately, but doesn't deliver on the promise of giving me false looking lashes. Perhaps it is difficult to provide that in the same formula that is completely waterproof.

Overall, I recommend this mascara if you are primarily looking for totally waterproof mascara that will not run or smear, but don't expect it to dramatically enhance volume or length.
Neha P.
Neha P.
Rockport, TX
19 reviews
I tried this mascara with high hopes because I love MAC's lipsticks and eyeshadows. This mascara was a disappointment. The brush is a traditional style mascara brush (not the rubber kind) and holds way too much product. So when it is applied, it gobs on my lashes. I have tried wiping it against the side of the tube and that helps a bit, but I still have to go back and comb through my lashes after application to get rid of the clumps. If I am not really quick with the combing, the mascara dries clumpy and then when I brush through it, it creates little black crumbs under my eyes. The consistency is watery and so I end up getting mascara on my eyelids and lash line during application (I don't have this problem with other mascaras). I tried wiping the brush off on a tissue and that helped to get a cleaner application. After combing out the clumps, this mascara looks just ok. I does not look like false lashes, but it does offer some lengthening. It wears pretty well throughout the day, but by the evening I do notice the beginning of raccoon eyes. It also has a bit of chemical smell that I don't care for. I wouldn't buy this mascara again.
jennifer o.
jennifer o.
Houston, TX
84 reviews
Badge Icon
Beauty Junkie Expert
Level 4
The worst mascara I have ever used! I've used better drugstore mascaras than this. If you want a nice thick voluminous look I would not recommend this mascara. This mascara, even after multiple coats could not give me the volume that my other mascaras could give me with one or two coats. The brush is nothing special, it reminds me of a slightly larger version of the sample sticks at sephora.
Dionysia S.
Dionysia S.
Newark, DE
17 reviews
Badge Icon
Beauty Junkie Expert
Level 3
This mascara has been great for me! First of all it does not smudge or does not stick any of my eyelashes together. Even with the first application my eyelashes seem longer and have a "fuller" look. if you want an even more dramatic look, you can reapply. In this way, first application gives you a more casual everyday look while the second one leaves you with a perfect look for a night-out!
Natalie L.
Natalie L.
Commack, NY
71 reviews
Badge Icon
Beauty Junkie Expert
Level 3
Review for: MAC False Lashes Mascara
this mascara is just ok, it made my eyes a little irratated, and it didnt supply me with the extensive dramatic lash i desire. there are much better mascaras on the market that are cheaper, or the same price that are btter quality. i wold recommmend this to someone who dreams of a naturul looking mascara
Jeneia P.
Jeneia P.
702 reviews
Badge Icon
Beauty Junkie Expert
Level 5
This was literally my first mascara I ever bought and I never had problem with it. It worked great until it ran out now did I go buy another one no I tried a different Mac mascara just because I felt like the mascara was like any other drug store mascara there was nothing special about the applier
Lety M.
Lety M.
Chino Hills, CA
90 reviews
This is a nice mascara that curls, has a dark black color, lasts a long time without smudging creates fuller lashes and really looks nice. However, it looks the same as the COVERGIRL Lash Blast Volume mascara in the orange tube. Covergirl is a better price. I will not repurchase the MAC one.
Susan G.
Susan G.
Wenona, IL
11 reviews
Hands down one of my top 3 mascaras. This baby will give you bold, beautiful, and glossy, long, full, and lush lashes in a few quick swipes. I mean Full and Lush! That fast who has time to mess with your make up especially mascara. No globs! No kidding. Excellent product.
Sabrina T.
Sabrina T.
330 reviews
Badge Icon
Beauty Junkie Expert
Level 5
I've used this many times in hopes that I would love it. It usually clumps my lashes up together and I would have to brush them out with another brush so I could get the results that I want. I don't think I would repurchase since it's very time consuming to use.
Sheina A.
Sheina A.
Brooklyn, NY
82 reviews
I'm so in love with these mascara. I work for DUTY FREE and one of our stores is mac and when I work in there or just stopping by I always put this on make my eyes looked bolder and stands out which I love since I have small Chinese kinda eyes lol!!...
Yvonne F.
Yvonne F.
Lemoore, CA
1 review
Has anyone used this? Does it clump?
Jami M.
Jami M.
25 reviews
I love MAC products but I haven't tried this yet. Is it worth the $?
Meagan R.
Meagan R.
Springfield, OR
7 reviews
Is this worth the splurge?
Jamie F.
Jamie F.
Pleasant Hill, CA
33 reviews
How well does this mascara last through the day? Does it flake off?
Jamie W.
Jamie W.
Piscataway, NJ
25 reviews
Badge Icon
Beauty Junkie Expert
Level 1
I've heard a lot of mixed reviews about MAC mascaras in general. Does this one really give a false lash effect (volume, curl)?

Join now to gain access to over 14 million product reviews, free full size samples, and the latest product news.

Get Started

Are you a Brand or Agency? Contact Us