I have the black one extra dimension 3D and I Looooveee it. It’s the best mascara if you have a few lashes. I lost lashes when my baby was born and more when I was breastfeeding, this mascara I don’t know how it does but it makes me looks like a have thousands of lashes, gives a lot of volume makes them super long. One of the best I have ever tried. And I have tried a lot of high ends but this is amazing.