I bought this to try. It is very pigmented and lasts most of the day. It was difficult for myself to use because of my hooded eyes. But I gave it to my daughter and she loved it. This product is easy to find and is sold at most drug stores and really is affordable.
I love the L'Oreal Colour Fresco Eye Shadow because it comes in a mini-lipstick tube package, is ultra compact and easy to use in seconds without needing an applicator wand. It goes on faster than liquid or powdered shadow and is easier to apply evenly. I like how long it lasts (all day). It comes in colors that help your natural eye color to really stand out. For example, the raisin shade causes my eyes to appear intensely green.
The Lorèal Colour Fresco Refreshing Creme Eyeshadow is not one of my go-to eye shadows. They go on creamy, but do not last. It leaves a slightly cold, slimy feeling on your eyelids. It clumps up in spots. I would not recommend this to anyone. It easily smears.