If you love winged eyeliner, you know tightlining is a very important step in perfecting the look. For months I’ve been searching for the perfect tightlining pencil, and thanks to [beauty box], it was delivered right to my door! This eyeliner from Lord & Berry is the darkest black liner I have stumbled upon in a few years, and even after applied to the waterline, it stays dark with no color dissipation. With a smooth application, the formula is creamy, yet solid, and doesn’t apply heavily, allowing for layers if needed. This liner stayed on all day for me, about 8 hours, with little fading on my waterline.