Dualistic Eye Pencil's creamy formula allows for an application that does not drag or pull. It is so fluid, soft and smudgeable that it works great as both a liner and an eye shadow base. Dualistic Eye Pencil is a perfect eye shadow base with a lasting pigment payoff. It works both under and over eye shadow, a truly versatile product. The creamy, pigment-rich formula is truly versatile, giving the eye maximum definition, dimension and blendability. Application Types: Use as an eye shadow base by smudging over the entire eyelid or use as a liner, both over and under eye shadow.