So, here's my dilemma: I don't have this exact liner. The LA Colors liquid eyeliner I use is in a kind of triangular bottle, with a long, thin cap (see photos). I can't review this particular product because it's not here on influenster,though the one that I do use is PERFECT. First of all, it's 2$ for one tube, which will last me at least 3 months; I use a LOT of eyeliner. It's extremely pigmented, even over all kinds of eyeshadow. The applicator is a nice long handle with a really thin brush that is flexible, and never sheds. I absolutely love how thin the brush is, I like to do long, tapered wings. This liner has unbelievable lasting power. You can rub it with water and it stays in tact, and sometimes when I forget to take it off before going to bed, it looks exactly the same in the morning. This is a long-lasting, water/sweat proof, extremely affordable liquid eyeliner. If you ever manage to find in online or in stores, pick it up!