I really loved this eyeliner in the deep raisin color. It is really amazing for someone (like myself) who is trying to ween themselves off of wearing black eyeliner everyday. The color is deep enough to make an impact but still softens your look much more than the black. The consistency of this liner is great and the color that is deposited is really full even with just one sweep across your lash line. It holds pretty well on your inner eye-lid as well despite the gel consistency. I give it 4 starts instead of 5 only because it seemed like I went through it much more quickly than any other liner that I've used. Now- in fairness, it may have been because I loved it so much that I used it more often - but really, I tend to wear the same eyeliner everyday. I may have just pressed down too hard and then inadvertently used more than what was required. Overall a great product though and for the quality, it is priced right.