I purchased this set to try out the formula. I found the formula for ice and skinny dip to be consistent but rose gold was slightly more on the glittery side. My least favorite is ice. I didn’t realize that the undertone is strong gold and peach, which looks better on slightly deeper skin or medium tones in my opinion. Overall great value and bang for your buck. Gotta be careful with them, though. Packaging is cute but not very protective.