JOAH Beauty's Color Haul Eyeshadow Palettes, specifically the "First Dance" and "Smokeshow" shades, offer a great entry point for those looking for affordable and versatile eyeshadow options. Both palettes are packed with a mix of shimmery and matte shades, offering a range of looks from soft and romantic to sultry and smoky. 🔸First Dance: This palette leans towards the romantic and neutral side. It features a beautiful selection of warm browns, soft pinks, and creamy beige tones, all perfect for creating everyday looks or soft, dreamy eye makeup. The shades are generally finely milled and blend effortlessly. The shimmer shades are particularly lovely, imparting a subtle, radiant glow. 🔸Smokeshow: As the name suggests, the Smokeshow palette is geared towards creating dramatic, smoky looks. It houses a rich selection of rusty browns, chocolate browns, and warm soft brown shades alongside warm taupes, shimmering creams and golds. This palette is excellent for achieving a sultry, evening look or a more intense eye makeup style. The shades are highly pigmented and provide excellent color payoff, allowing for bold and smoky looks. ▪️Overall Impression: Both palettes offer incredible value for their price point. The quality is surprisingly good, with smooth, blendable textures and decent pigmentation. The color selections in each palette are well-curated and versatile, making them suitable for a range of skin tones and makeup preferences. ▪️Pros: 🔸Affordable: These palettes are incredibly budget-friendly. 🔸Versatile: The shade range allows for various looks, from everyday to dramatic. 🔸Blendable: The textures are smooth and easy to blend. 🔸Good Pigmentation: Especially in the Smokeshow palette. 🔸Beautiful Shimmer Shades: The shimmers are finely milled and add a lovely glow. ▪️Cons: 🔸Some fall out: A few of the shades, particularly the darker ones, might experience a bit of fallout during application. 🔸Not the most unique shade selection: The color stories are classic and don't offer groundbreaking shade ranges. ▪️Recommendation: If you're looking for affordable and versatile eyeshadow palettes, the JOAH Beauty Color Haul palettes are an excellent choice. First Dance is ideal for those who prefer softer, everyday looks, while Smokeshow is perfect for those who like to experiment with bolder, smoky eye makeup. While they might not be the most revolutionary palettes in terms of shade selection, they certainly deliver great quality for their price and are a fantastic starting point for anyone looking to build their eyeshadow collection.

I really feel great about using this product because it’s cruelty free! I really enjoyed the creamy texture of the eyeshadows. I also liked the versatility of the color story! You can do a soft, sultry look or you can do a bolder, nighttime look. I was unsure about the beads in this palette because I’ve never seen anything like it, which I appreciate for being creative and unique. But I grew to like it! The eyeshadows blend nicely and for me, personally, I think the pigment lasts for a good 8 hours!

It replaced a couple of my other higher end palettes because it has the mattes and shimmers I need in one place. The color payoff isn’t the absolute best I’ve tried but I would still reach for it over my other ones.