It caked and creased for me. I know sao many people that love this. I personally dont. But it does truly depend on your skin. I have dry undereyes and this settled right into them instantly. It was hard to blend, and remained cakey. I tried it with under eye primers, my moisturizer, eye my eye shadow primer, etc..without anything. It just didnt work for me. So I gave it to a friend and she loves it! Good luck, and I hope it works for you!