I did not buy the lavender cupcake one, But I did buy the Rainbow sherbet one as a gift for a friend, who happened to also let me watch it Via Snapchat. The fizz on this was okay, give that the cupcake was 10$, I was expecting a little more fizz. It did tint her bath water slightly, but not enough to make a mess or stain, which is always a plus too. She did say the smell was heavenly as well. I thought it smelled good as well when I bought the product, it wasn't too heavy of a smell either. I would definitely buy one for myself to try as soon as I get a tub, but I think it will be a special treat, rather than a monthly expense.