HBG’s eyeliner is one of the only eyeliners that actually stays on without running or smearing. Very happy with the color and staying power.

I bought this on Iherb.com. It has some pigment but my eyeliner gets really smudged. The ingredients are all natural so for that kinda healthy product $11-$15 is pretty affordable. It was overall an OK product. Probably won't buy it again because I want something really good.

This is a nice natural eyeliner and I love the ingredients but I wish it was more waterproof because it does smear sometimes.