TRUST ME, YOU NEED THIS!! PS: If it "seems not so pigmented," it's in need of a shake and press. Shake well for 30 seconds then press the tip 4 times on all sides, then it should be good to go for another month before it needs shaking again. I have tried every single liquid, pencil gel, liquid gel, you name it...and this tops them ALL! First, this is perfect for creating that perfect cat eye, tight line, perfect little flick or a natural line, both up and down. It's also perfect for painting on exquisite designs. It is the ONLY liner that does not leave that black half moon on my upper lid, regardless of how long it's been on, all day or all night -even through sleeping! Honestly, this is like a fine tipped sharpie for the eyes that dries instantly but still gives you a moment to blend out if that is what you want to do. I have both the fat and skinny and I can't be without them!