Very good, long lasting, affordable and great shade range. Definitely recommend trying it. I have the shade called 15 "Vintage Rose". This lip liner also has a sharpener.

I’m not satisfied with this lipliner. The color is nice but texture felt rough and uncomfortable on my lips, and it didn’t glide on smoothly like I expected. It’s not for me.

these are a great value for the price. The color payoff is good. The packaging is easy to use. It applies very well and I will buy these forever. Big proposal was the shade that I used.