I've used this eyeliner for about a week or so now, and I have been pleasantly surprised with how amazing it is! For $2.99, this is a steal! It hasn't smudged on my hooded eyes, and the tip has stayed nice and sharp without splitting at the end. It claims to be waterproof, but it definitely is not. However, I prefer that my daily eyeliner is not waterproof as long as it doesn't smudge and stays on all day, and this fits the bill. It's very pigmented as well, so there hasn't been any "skipping" upon application. Would definitely highly recommend. I think I like it ever better than my Maybelline Master Precise felt tip eyeliner, which has been my holy grail drugstore eyeliner for years!