I've had this product for a long time and for some reason i thought that i didn't like it. I used to use this to take off my eye makeup before i started using coconut oil but bringing a jar of coconut oil with me when i travel isn't very practical so i usually bring makeup wipes, but when i recently went to a music festival i was out of wipes and realized i had a bottle of this still so i brought it with. This takes off my waterproof mascara with minimal effort and doesn't feel at all like i'm ripping my lashes off by trying to get it off. This product does claim to be oil free and it seems to leave an initial film around my eyes immediately after using it but following with a toner takes it right off. It removes eye makeup like a dream and takes off face makeup too, no problem. It is the equate brand so it is very inexpensive, i would definitely recommend it.