I was disappointed by this specific shade because the formulation was just so much clumpier and less pigmented than the darker shade I got. And the handle was bent. At first I thought it was meant to look that way but it’s not. I contacted EM cosmetics about the defective quality and they issued a refund thankfully. Giving three stars because the other shade I got was so much better in both quality and pigment. So I guess it depends which color you pick.