e.l.f. Waterproof Eyeliner Pen
BY E.L.F. COSMETICS
(5,453)
Description
This waterproof eyeliner pen enhances the lash line with rich waterproof color.
How To Use
Hold Applicator At A Slight Angle And Apply Color To The Base Of The Lashes.
Use A Light Touch For Thin Lines Or A Firmer Touch For Thicker Lines.
Removal Is Easy, Use A Water Based Makeup Remover.
Best Stored With Tip Down For Ultimate Color Saturation.
Ingredients:
Water (Aqua), Styrene/Acrylates/Ammonium Methacrylate Copolymer, Polysorbate 20, Ethylhexylpalmitate, Peg-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Xanthan Gum, Benzyl Alcohol, Methylchloroisothiazolinone, Methylisothiazolinone
May Contain:dc Black #2 (Ci 77266), Iron Oxides (Ci 77491, Ci 77492, Ci 77499), Titanium Dioxide (Ci 77891), Manganese Violet (Ci 77742), Ultramarines (Ci 77007), Chromium Hydroxide Green (Ci 77289), Yellow 5 Lake (Ci 19140), Ferric Ferrocyanide (Ci 77510), Blue 1 Lake (Ci 42090), Red 40 Lake (Ci 16035)
Top Questions See all 1,324 Q&A
e.l.f. Waterproof Eyeliner Pen
Reviews (5,453)
Q&A (356)
Media (251)
REVIEWS
PRODUCT HIGHLIGHTS
- " I have tried a numerous waterproof eyeliner pens and non of them seemed to last for even an hour , I would put them on in the morning and in the afternoon I would look like if someone had punched me in the eye , so one day I decided to try this e.l.f. waterproof eyeliner pen because it was just one dollar plus I had nothing to lose . I honestly was expecting another no good eyeliner just like the rest of the ones that I've tried , but I definitely was wrong . The product lasts for hours I put it on at 10:30am & when I come home from college at 9:00pm it is still there and I only put make up on once a day I never retouch plus it doesn't smudge and it also cleans off very easily . It's been a year since I first tried it and I wouldn't change this product for anything :)" in 463 reviews
- "I love this product this is my favorite liquid/pen black eyeliner. the price is perfect and its easy to find." in 318 reviews
- "Winged eyeliner was something I have always wanted to do, but never thought I could. I bought this and was able to do it on the first try and the product lasted all night! Best thing is it was super cheap! Great buy!" in 240 reviews
- "However, it tends to fade on me to where it can barely be seen by the end of the day and the felt tip dries out very quickly after first use." in 85 reviews
- "this is amazing for anyone that uses a pin they know it comes of very easy so for this to even be waterprof it so amazing" in 34 reviews
5,453 reviews
This eyeliner has been my least favorite liner ever used. Following my initial purchase, this eyeliner had a low quality level and ran out of ink within a ridiculously short period. Thus, upon using this eyeliner pen, it provided zero to little precision. As I tried drawing a winged liner line, this pen often skipped over my skin and applied blotchy. I believe I could have obtained more precision if using a Crayola drawing marker. Also, the next reason why I did not like this eyeliner pen is because it ran out of ink within a couple of days. Despite it not being the most precise liner, I was still eager to use this liner to its completion. However, it was completely bereft of ink within less than 48 hours. Thus, I do not consider this product worth even its low price tag. Lastly, I have enjoyed certain other Elf products. But in the case of this eyeliner, the only positive attribute I can find is that now I have the knowledge to never again purchase this liner. Perhaps I purchased one from a bad batch, but I will still not wish to purchase this liner again.
Purchased at: Walmart
I wish I could give this more stars! I absolutely love this eyeliner and I pray they don't stop selling it. For $2, you can't beat it. It stays on all day without smudging. I've never had any issues with it causing my eyes to tear either. I highly recommend this product. It comes in two colors, chocolate and black.
Review for: Black more...
This is definitely a "get what you paid for" eyeliner for me. I bought it because I just wanted a small makeup kit at work (as I usually don't leave time to do it at home) that wasn't breaking the bank. The first few times, this eyeliner worked super well (which is why this isn't a 1 star review). It was dark without having to go over the line multiple times and the felt tip was easy to control. It made the nice lines I needed it to. We are probably about 2 weeks into this eyeliner (not every day use) and it's already dropped dramatically in opaqueness. I also always made sure the cap was on securely (as it is a bit finicky for me). Essentially, I would really recommend this only if you are in a pinch (like maybe away on a short holiday and forgot your eyeliner) with a very tight budget.
This is a great eyeliner for everyday use. It has a really strong pigment and the liner aplication part is still intact. It makes the application super easy to do. It doesn't last if you mess with your eyes a lot but if you don't touch your eyes it definitely last. I recommend this product.
Purchased at: Walmart
I would give this zero stars if I could!! By far the WORST liner i've ever used for one crazy reason. I bought this in black, it applied decently enough. For some reason, when it comes in contact with any liquid, tears, makeup remover, rain, etc. it changes to a turquoise blue shade that is then waterproof and impossible to remove if out in public or without proper remover. That aside, if you cry or just rub your eye for any reason, not only is your liner ruined, it becomes a turquoise MESS far worse than running, smearing or smudging of a non waterproof liner. This stained my face blue for 24 hours and even worse, the white of my eye for the day. And this is liner that began black. Straight in the trash is where it went.
Review for: Black more...
This eyeliner starts out fantastic. Sharp lines and very black. However, the tip either splits or gets caught up in the tube or falls out a bit. It also dries up quicker than I’d like and I have to buy a new one but it’s pretty cheap so not a big deal.
Very little transfer
Very little transfer
Purchased at: CVS
Review for: Black more...
This is one of the most terrible makeup products I have ever used. It doesn’t go on well because the tip is way too thick, so if you try to do a wing, it’s a big blob, and if you try to apply it to your waterline, it takes up half your lid, so I really wouldn’t recommend.
This is really the only product I ever use for eyeliner. It goes on so easily, and stays on all day. Truly is waterproof as well. There is some discrepancy within the type of pen you'll get. Sometimes you'll get duller ones and sometimes you'll get really sharp ones (they are brushes, but if you get what I mean).
Both are useful for different areas. I typically use the sharp ones for the wing part, and the duller ones for the waterline on my top eyelid. This product can dry out, but most last me for months!
Both are useful for different areas. I typically use the sharp ones for the wing part, and the duller ones for the waterline on my top eyelid. This product can dry out, but most last me for months!
Review for: Black more...
I picked up this E.L.F. eyeliner pen in black from CVS in a pinch one day for some liquid eyeliner. It only cost me $3, so it totally saved me that day!!! The eyeliner itself applies liquidy and smooth. Not patchy or messy at all. Unfortunately, I found that it doesnt stay in place very well. It completely smeared just from touching my eye hours after it was applied, as if it never actually set. I use it now to practice my wings since it comes off so easily, but probably wont be wearing it on a day where my eye looks will matter. Spend the extra $$ and go with something like Stila for a good liquid pen.
Q & A
Does it run out fast or did i just get a bad one
Like This?
1
Ornida G.
2 years, 6 months ago
I think I may have gotten a bad one too. There's a lot of positive reviews but I had a bad experience. The tip is pretty dry but the base has a lot of ink. But it's a reasonable price I may spring for another.
Does it ever dry out fast?
Like This?
1
Vanessa M.
2 years, 7 months ago
You have to make sure the cap is on really tight, because I haven't closed mine all the way before and it's dried out by the next day! The product does its job and lasts pretty long as far as eyeliner pens go, but I would recommend the liquid eyeliner because I've literally had mine for 6 months and it hasn't run out yet and I do winged eyeliner every day!
How well does this eyeliner work?
Like This?
1
Alison A.
2 years, 7 months ago
It works really well! It really does not smear AT ALL and it is very much waterproof! I think it works great and I would definitely recommend it!
It's waterproof really?
Like This?
1
Michelle V.
5 months, 1 week ago
I don't even think you need water to take this stuff off....All I did was touch it and it came off. Pass on this one!
Does this smudge? Is it long lasting?
Like This?
1
Michelle V.
5 months, 1 week ago
It smudges, wipes off...this reminds me of play makeup when you were a kid. Dont waste your money!
PHOTOS & VIDEOS
See All Photos & Videos
e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner
based on 4,446 reviews
e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyeliner & Shadow Stick
based on 409 reviews
e.l.f. Shimmer Eyeliner Pencil
based on 1,093 reviews
e.l.f. Precision Liquid Eyeliner
based on 868 reviews
e.l.f. Brightening Eyeliner
based on 574 reviews
e.l.f. Disney Good vs Evil Eyeliner Collection Gift Set
based on 137 reviews
e.l.f. Eyeliner
based on 360 reviews
e.l.f. Mineral Waterproof Shadow Liner
based on 187 reviews
