I absolutely love the brown sigar version of this product. It's an extremely good lip exfoliant,especially for the cheap price! It doesn't cut my lips,nor was it too harsh,but it did remove the dead skin and left my lips soft and nice. Will definitely repurchase the brown sugar one.
The cherry one,however...I believe I received a bad one. It was really rough and did wind up scratching my lips and making them bleed. But I asked my friend who had also bought the cherry kind,and they said theirs worked wonderfully,so I'm guessing I just got a bad one. The taste was sweet and nice,so I'd maybe be willing to give it a try again. Hopefully it doesn't hurt me again. e.l.f. Cosmetics Lip Exfoliator