I think the main reason most people buy these items is for collector's value - not necessarily expecting the greatest quality make up. Having said that these glosses a bit disappointing in the pigment color factor. I bought 2 of the Mulan versions and both put barely any color on my lip. Just more of a glossy look, if your lips are naturally pale/light in color you might notice a kiss of pink. They are a bit sticky/thick but they smell wonderful. The packaging is gorgeous and sturdy, like something you could have gotten from a Mac or Sephora collection. All in all it performed like I expected with these drugstore Disney collabs.