I used to use Maybelline Fit Me foundation, and it's a pretty good product. I don't like the smell but that's really the only issue with it. It never made me break out--like you, I used Covergirl and it wasn't compatible with my skin. However, if you're comfortable moving to an online brand, I swear by BH Cosmetics' products, and have recently switched to their liquid foundation. It's cruelty-free, paraben-free, and vegan, which definitely has made a difference in how my skin reacts to the product. I'd say it's medium coverage and it leaves my skin looking really natural and glowy. And it feels really lightweight on my face! Hope this helps!!