I previously used Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless but felt it was too matte for my combination skin. I have been searching for a foundation that is medium-heavy coverage, not too matte but will take away shine. I think I may have found it. I had my daughter help me match at the store. I applied some to my jawline and she said it was lighter than my neck so I went with it, the 805 (lightest shade there). I ended up taking the time to look on Amazon and saw that it ends up darkening 1-2 shades after it oxidizes so I was glad I went with the one I did.
The application with a triangle sponge went well. The pump makes it much quicker to apply, since I don't have to pour some on my hand. Right after applying I took a picture and it definitely white washed me, I looked like a ghost. But I finished my makeup and I felt it had darkened to just the right shade. For comparison, I ended up taking a picture in sunlight and again in the office bathroom and I'm still very happy with the shade.
The only downside is, considering it's a 3-in-1 that is supposed to help skip the primer step, I feel I can still use primer. Being in my mid-30s, I am getting fine lines around my eyes and on my forehead. I feel this foundation still settles into them.
I will see how it works with my Maybelline hydrating primer, overall I'm satisfied with this foundation.

I LOVE this foundation. It is my everyday go-to. It goes on and stays on, and it has fantastic coverage. I love the pump to dispense and I love that they’re cruelty free as well. I swear this is waterproof as well, but I could be crazy. I love this stuff. That being said, if you have dry skin, I highly recommend you moisturize before putting your makeup on. If you forget it does cling to dry spots a little bit, it’s nothing terrible, but for best results moisturize before application.

This is my absolute favorite foundation. I’ve tried Tarte Amazonian Clay, Dior liquid and spray, Mac, pretty much all the major, raved about foundations, but I always come back to this one. I have combo/oily, acne prone skin, and with benefit porefessional primer, this foundation stays on and locked all day. I do get the occasional build up around the cracks of my nose and I do blot once or twice a day, but this is just the tried and true #1 choice for me!

This is one of my favorites it’s in the shade ivory, it isn’t full coverage but buildable, I normally have problem with foundations sticking to dry patches on my nose even with moisturizer and primer, but this doesn’t happen when I use this, I will definitely buy again. The only downside is it can get cakey and crease if I apply to much or don’t use setting powder. COVERGIRL Outlast Stay Fabulous 3-In-1 Foundation

I had really high expectations for this product, considering it was one of those raved about products on youtube and I could barely find any negative reviews for it (even from my fellow oily people) - meaning I had to try.  I believe the shade I tested was Buff Beige, which was pretty close to my skin tone, but maybe just a tad bit too light, even after oxidizing.  This BARELY oxidized on me, but enough for me to tell it got darker. 

First, THIS HAS A PUMP.  Major win.  It went on soooo smooth, felt great, and blended well.  The coverage was AMAZING!! Definitely a very high medium if not full - I've got mild acne and redness.  I was like, great!  This is gonna be the one!  I'll just pick up the next shade darker! 

WRONG!  THIS MADE ME SO FREAKING OILY!  I am an extremely oily skin girl, and no matter what I do I can't seem to stay matte.  So I'm used to it.  But this, THIS was a whole new level of oily.  I usually only need to blot 2-3 times a day (I COULD do more but I don't NEED to) to look presentable.  With this foundation I would have NEEDED to blot TWO-THREE times OR MORE EACH HOUR TO LOOK DECENT.  My boyfriend said it was the most oily he's ever seen me and even joked and said I could probably start an oil lamp with how much oil was on my face. 

I did the same exact routine I always do with the same products, so obviously something in this foundation did not agree with my skin.  It wore off the sides of my nose and caused my eyeliner to transfer to my upper lid and smear in the corners of my eye (which never happens to me ever, so no it's not the eyeliner) because of how oily those areas got.  And this was all within under five hours sitting in an office, not getting sweaty or moving whatsoever, in the AIR CONDITIONING!

By the end of the day (it got even worse because after I left the office, I had to work an event outside for my other job) it looked so textured and gross (which I blame on the mounds of oil) and I just wanted to get it off.  I absolutely have no idea what everyone is talking about when they say it stays in place all day and doesn't make them oily, because I certainly didn't have that experience.  Wish I could have made it work because the coverage and look was great (minus the oil of course), but I don't have the time or the money to blot a million times a day.

I recommend for normal skin, maybe even combo skin that needs good coverage, but from my experience, if you have very oily skin like me then I say stay away.  In my opinion, the Covergirl Clean Matte BB is wayyyy better, and that's saying something because that really isn't the best thing out there.
 

I don't know who told CoverGirl that ivory was basically beige, but I believe they should be fired. I've always had problems finding my perfect match in this line, and it really sucks when the lightest shade is too dark for you! I applied this foundation using my beauty blender, and it went on like a dream. If I disregarded the fact that it wasn't my shade, it looked pretty dang flawless. This however did not last long as the beigh-ish color on my skin began to oxidize. I must have looked insane to the people who saw me out grocery shopping! Makeup faux pas aisle one! The coverage was nice, it didn't break down funny on my skin and as I said it looked pretty flawless... had it not been too dark and then even oxidize on my  skin. This experience almost made me want to give up the hunt for my holy grail foundation. Thankfully I was able to break that mood and test even more.

It's a cheap brand so don't expect crazy amounts of coverage, but it works well enough. It's all I've used for years because my skin is sensitive and I don't want to risk it flaring up. Overall, it's not expensive and you can cover your blemishes. Just be careful of pores still poking through.

This is a good Covergirl foundation for sure! It’s super duper cheap and gets the job done. It isn’t the best one out there but in terms of drugstore quality it’s pretty good! It covers my rosacea and any acne I have. You also get a lot of product for the price too!

This is a pretty good foundation, it just doesn’t stay on all day for me. I have some dry skin, but I’m definitely more oily, so it unfortunately does break down. I did find the perfect match though just by looking at it in the store!

I just purchased this foundation and I really like it. It covers all areas that need to me covered and last for several hours. I really love that it last during a day of work. My face doesn’t seem to be as shiny hours after applying.