This is the only Covergirl makeup product I have ever liked besides the LashBlast Mega Volume Mascara. This eyeliner applies very pigmented and smooth. It is affordable and worth the money. It doesn't last long on the waterline, but I expect that of drugstore eyeliners. It looks great on the upper or lower lash line and doesn't tug on my eyes. I recommend this to anyone looking for a good inexpensive eyeliner.