I have the Covergirl Lipperfection Lip Liner in the shade Seduce. It is an absolutely perfect nude, slightly on the pinky side and ever so pigmented. It is a traditional sharpenable pencil which I like (although the wood is smooth black making it more aesthetically pleasing and softer to the touch), because it means you get more product as the "lead" runs right through to the end of the pencil without need for mechanics in the end. What makes this one of my favorite pencils, aside from being very pigmented for a nude, is how long it lasts. Which is all day. If I swatch this on my hand with all my lip liners, this one is the last one standing. For a nude, that is surprising and makes this product a certain re-purchase for me. It also has a super creamy texture that is easy to apply (remember in the 90s when you had to hold your eye and lip pencils in a lighter flame to soften them before use?!) and only needs one application for opaque coverage. I usually use this with my COVERGIRL Lip Perfection Jumbo Gloss Balm
in Cotton Candy Twist over the top for a perfect glossy pinky nude lip but I have been known to wear it alone as a matte nude - it's that good.