This mascara is absolute garbage, along with everything else in the Katy Perry Covergirl line. For drugstore mascara, the price is pretty steep for what it’s worth. The spoolie applicator is the worst one I’ve ever used. The spoolie is oversized while the bristles on it are minuscule. This makes it pick up a pound of product, causing extreme clumping and makes a huge mess. It doesn’t even elongate your lashes, it just coats your lashes with product. Due to this, it’s not even buildable, it just makes the messiness worse. Also, to top it all off, it took barely anytime at all for it to flake off into my under eye area! I tossed both colors away after my first use, which is shame because I was very excited for the blue. You don’t see blue mascaras too often, too bad this kind isn’t worth a penny. I’ll never buy anything in this line again.

This is my favorite mascara and I’m super picky! I used to pull out my eyelashes when I got stressed out or has anxiety so I’ve been super picky about the type I use. I forgot my mascara while out of town and ran to the local cvs and ended up buying this stuff. I use two coats and run an old empty brush through them after each coat to make sure nothing gets clumpy. I’m so glad I found this stuff and the price is awesome! I had it on in the picture below and this was about 5 hours after applying.

I use this mascara as my daily mascara, while most might use it as their
night out mascara. I purchased mine at my local Walmart. I have bought
this multiple times. It takes a while to get used to the texture of the
product, just because it's so thick and sometimes can be very clumpy. It
is super hard to remove all of the mascara, but I have found using Clinique Rinse-Off Eye Makeup Solvent makes removal so much easier. Clinique Rinse-Off Eye Makeup Solvent

I was so disappointed to say the least. I was really hoping this mascara would be as fierce as Katy! The most important part of the mascara for me is the brush. That is a deal breaker, because it all leads up to the application and how your eyelashes will end up looking. The brush is shaped funky and all the mascara just clumps up in the middle so every time I try to apply there’s a glob of product on my eyelashes. It’s a hot mess! Don’t recommend!

This mascara is horrible and I won't use it ever again, I already tossed it out. The wand is giant but the bristles are fairly sparse, meaning the wand picks up 3X as much mascara as it should, which ends up transferring gobs of product onto your lashes - not dry clumps, but big gobs of wet mascara that end up transferring all over when you blink. This mascara is messy and even touching up with a q-tip and combing through my lashes doesn't make it look decent. I suppose this might work okay if you have long, full lashes that just need pigment or if you really like the spidery lash look. It's a shame that this formula comes in blue, there aren't enough drugstore formulas that do and this one is such a disaster I wouldn't even use it if I wanted a blue mascara. I gave this 2 stars instead of 1 because the formula didn't get into my eyes, it wasn't scented or irritating, and it didn't give me panda eyes or flake

I looove the WATERPROOF version of this product. When I curl my lashes and put this on, the lashes stay curled and don’t falter at all!!! And the waterproof one truly is waterproof and stays completely curled and looks amazing!! This is my favorite mascara and you could use for a fake eyelash free look and still make your eyes pop!!

I just bought this mascara a few days ago. So far, I'm not loving it. The application brush sucks. The bristles are not defined very well, so it makes it hard to apply without it looking like a clumpy mess. It's also oddly shaped in a spiral, so it hits the top of my eyelids which isn't a good look. It's still new, so I'll still give it a chance. But it goes on very thin. Not very buildable. I put on 3 layers and it still looks more like a lash stain than an actual mascara. It was about $9. The only think I like is the packaging. The white tube makes it easy to find in my makeup bag. I hope it will redeem itself as I continue using!

This was such a disappointment. The brush looked as if it'd do a decent job at separation, lash coating, etc. Im not sure if it was either the formula alone, the brush, or both, that caused it to be messy, thick and clumpy. No metter how hard I tried, It clumped my lashes! Lol, such a bummer, would not recommend.

The brush is a little weird and picks up a lot of product so it takes some time getting used to but besides that I love this mascara. It was on sale at target and it makes my lashes super long and full! Lashes can get clumpy if you’re not careful but take your time with it and you’ll have beautiful lashes!

I bought this on a whim after running out of another mascara. I'd have to say though, this pleasantly surprised me! The very black shade is perfectly dark and not at all brown or green tinged. It also separates, lengthens, and holds a curl fantastically! Color me impressed, covergirl