The mascara of course is great, I've had many tubes of it over the years, the liquid eyeliner was great for a long time, I've also gone through tons of them, but the last one I bought was so watery I was completely disappointed, so I just recently stopped using the liquid eyeliner. I don't feel like taking another chance on it. I used it for so long, it was my go to liquid eyeliner, it was just dramatically different the last time. The eyeshadow stick, I had the silver/plum one before, it was decent, but I think those are discontinued now. Maybe just stick to the mascara.