Not a fan of this mascara at ALL. I have used dozens of mascaras from different brands over my lifetime and this one was clumpy and made my lashes stick together. I always had to use make-up remover and scrub like crazy to get it off (most other waterproof mascaras come mostly off with just soap and water and a good scrub). It also stuck to my lashes and I lost a bunch of my lashes due to that. Not one I'd recommend.