The NYC Liquid Eyeliner holds a special place in my makeup journey, particularly during my high school days. What made it truly remarkable was its fantastic performance at an unbelievably affordable price. Priced at a mere $3, it was an absolute steal and became my holy grail for achieving the perfect winged eyeliner look. What set this eyeliner apart was its formula and ability to deliver a rich black color that, despite its low cost, competed with much pricier alternatives. The smooth glide during application was a standout feature, ensuring a seamless and effortless experience that made achieving precise lines, especially for winged eyeliner, a breeze. The brush applicator of the NYC Liquid Eyeliner allowed for meticulous detailing. Its versatility in smoothly adapting to various styles, from subtle lines to elaborate wings, was one of the reasons it became a staple in my makeup bag. The affordability of this gem made it accessible to many, and its discontinuation in the states is truly disheartening.