I would give this toy an A+ if I could! Two cats have absolutely loved this toy in our house! We have a total of three of these carrots, and they are a big hit. Even with one cat who is a biter and rough on her toys, the damage to the toy is pretty minimal. Just a quick sew at the top seam to keep the catnip inside, and this toy was back in action. I would recommend this particular toy the most out of all the varieties (banana, pepper, etc.).