While we continue to feed Echko a raw diet, we wanted a training treat that was a dehydrated raw product. The associate at Pet Valu recommended these. Although they are kibble toppers, we feed them dry as treats. Echko loves them and definitely is always coming back for more. Luckily, since this is a balanced dehydrated raw dog food, we don't worry about giving him too many on busy training days. Our only concern is how long the ingredient list is. We would have rathered a short simple ingredient list, but you can't win them all, eh.