My dog kind of liked Cesar Canine Cuisine with Chicken and Veal but did not finish which sadly to say my cat likes this food since she finished it off. Maybe she just did not like the veal since i know Hershey likes anything Chicken Flavored. Maybe I will try it again with her and see if she likes it, I did not find the pate look of food or the smell all the appealing but Hey I am the Human where as she is the dog, the one eating the dog food. Does Dog Food smell better to dogs and well since cats since my cat Pumpkin helped herself and finished it off???