Carmex all the way - EOS made the whole area around my lips break out in a rash. I used to use chapstick but do not anymore because that brand tests on animals. Carmex is cruelty free and does great on my lips.
Carmex any day! EOS is not all that great. I bought so many EOS balms bc everyone on youtube raves over them. & honestly I applied more EOS over & over then any other balm i tried. it faded & didn't help moisten my lips!