Tragically terrible. I received this in my Birchbox either a month or two ago, and it was the worst eyeshadow I had ever tried on. The pigmentation is really bad, even for the darker shade. You can barely see them. I had to apply at least 5 layers of eyeshadow to get just a little close to the pigmentation of the Naked palette. It had a lot of fallout, too. Also, this is not long-wearing whatsoever. Color faded within a few hours of having left my house. Huge disappointment. Will not be using these shadows ever again.