I got this in a little kit for Christmas. I like the wand a lot. The mascara goes on evenly with no clumping. Once dry my lashes feel softer than with other mascaras. The only downfall is that because it isn't waterproof after several hours there is a bit of smudging on my lower lashes and it starts to flake off. I've had much worse smudging with UD perversion, though. Overall a pretty good mascara but I'd love a waterproof version.