I really liked these when they first came out. I had the brown and black and wore them frequently. My only issue was how much time it could take. These were really great for smudging and somewhat for creating a smokey eye back then. I went back to these a few months ago, but they were dried out. Wish I'd tried them again before they died. So many new products to have compared them too. Wouldn't mind receiving them again to check them out.

I prefer using waterproof pens when doing a winged liner because they last all day. I tend to use this for my lower lashes. I gave it a 4 star because it did wear off after 8 hours. I’m not a good judge of that since I’m super oily and in a humid climate.

Best line n brush for a smooth finish I  black or brown a little pricey and hard to find without going on line