Beautiful color, but I prefer my lip liners to be waterproof. I’ve only used this a handful of times.

I love this liner! It goes on so buttery smooth.  The color payoff is amazing and i can literally fill my entire lip with just this liner and go!  

The product glides really easily and doesn't tug at my lips at all. I actually prefer the liner over the liquid lip because it's creamy and much more precise (I don't like how the tip of the doe foot applicator is flimsy for the liquid lip). The pigmentation is beautiful and doesn't emphasize any cracks in my lips.