i recently got two of these eyeliners form ulta, one in brown and the other in navy blue. they are very creamy and pigmented. they glide on the eye super easy no tugging. i like the blue one better than the brown just cuz its a different color and its a bit lighter than i thought it would be. again though i have the hardest time finding a eyeliner that is waterproof that will stay on my waterline. it did not last all day ,but it did last longer than any other i have tried.