Beautiful packaging and colors. I got the plum set, uptown girl I think, in the three piece set. I love that the formula is gluten free. The lipstick case is a novelty item— it’s heavy not not as heavy as guerlain rouge g cases. The charm is cute! The lipsticks are creamy, but on the drier side, and fully opaque. The colors are beautiful. The finish is satin and when I put them on, they “stick” and do not feel like they will budge. You can absolutely find these colors and formulas in less expensive brands…but I just wanted this set. I also like how easy it is to interchange the lipstick in the primary case. Honestly, the temp cases are pretty great too.