I continue to buy these because they last me awhile, but they definitely are not my dogs favorite. These have a really weird texture. My dog is 7 pounds so he's very small and struggles to chew crunchy things. I thought these would be great for him, but they're so dense that he even struggles to chew these. I've had to cut them into halves and fourths because I worry my dog will try to swallow them whole since chewing them is a challenge. After I finish this bag, I probably won't buy more. I definitely don't feel guilty giving him more than one though since they are so small! That's a positive.