Liquid liner is too thin and after a few uses it started to clump and dry up. The bristles started separating in the bottle and thinning making the application look a clumpy mess. Comes off with the slightest tears so it’s definitely not waterproof.

This eyeliner is unfortunately everything i want to avoid. Its streaky, thin, not precise, and you can literally feel it dried on your eyelid. As you can see in the swatches a single line is patchy and not at all fully black. If you do more layers it finally gets color payoff but its STILL streaky and becomes uncomfortably thick and dry. You cannot get a "sharp" wing with this! Its super cheap, but seriously just spend a bit more and get a quality liner. Now i am on the hunt for another black eyeliner, as this is a complete miss

The photos are about 35 minutes apart. I live in a dorm that was built in the mid 1800s and basically LIVE in front of a fan. So part of why this is runny is because I had air blowing on me. But it's also super watery and not waterproof. It is a super precise eyeliner. Nice jet black and a nice price. But it comes off too fast and is not resistant to sweat which is what I need. I think the ultimate worst thing is that it burned. I got a little in my eye when applying which makes sense. But it also burned 30 minutes later