For a cheap eyeliner, this one works a lot better than I was expecting. I got it in the shade Beautiful which applies as a very dark black. It went on smoothly and transferred well into my water line with great pigmentation. It wears off a little bit throughout the day, and probably more if you have oily skin, but it stayed on better than a lot of cheap eyeliners. It was easy to wash off also. Overall I would recommend this product if you are on a budget!