First things first, this is not a lipstick and it is definitely not a lip liner. I would categorize this in the tinted balm / creamy lip gloss category. The differentiation for me is the method of applying the product as well as the end result. It is a "stick" form as opposed to a wand applicator, but I find that most lipsticks & lip liners are significantly more saturated in color and last longer. This product went on smooth and creamy, but it didn't have a ton of pop to the color and it didn't last very long.
That being said, it's a pretty darn cool tinted lip balm. The dual pigmented stick did give some definition to my lips...not so much that you could tell I was wearing two different colors on my lips but almost a "highlight/contour" effect. The color was pretty and complimented my natural lip color well, and it made my lips suuupppeeer soft. Overall, a pretty neat product, but I took off one star....because it sure as heck isn't a lipstick,