Woah there, it looks like your browser is out of date.

To get the best experience, please update your browser.

Benefit Most Wanted Mascara Line-Up

Benefit Most Wanted Mascara Line-Up


4.5 out of 5 stars
  • 5 Stars62%
  • 4 Stars34%
  • 3 Stars3%
  • 2 Stars0%
  • 1 Star0%
4.59 / 5 based on 29 Reviews

Product Description

Unlike in our love lives, we don't believe in "the one" when it comes to mascara. Instead, we're all about having options to suit everything from casual daytime looks to a big night out. This set lets us mix and match with three Benefit Cosmetics mascara minis: They're Real! for ultimate length, Roller Lash for extra curl and lift, and BADgal for dramatic volume. No matter which mascara suits our mood, we're prepping our lashes with lash-defining They're Real! Tinted Primer, which boosts volume and is packed with conditioning vitamin B5 to keep lashes soft and healthy. They're Real! Push-Up Liner rounds out this set of favorites with matte gel color and an innovative flexible tip for a sleek line that completes any look. see more...

Top Questions See all 5 Q&A

  • What's the difference between these mascaras? I haven't used this...1 Answers
  • Does Benefit do animal testing on their products? Be the first to answer!
  • What is the difference between all of these? Are any clumpier tha...1 Answers
Benefit Most Wanted Mascara Line-Up
Benefit Most Wanted Mascara Line-Up
Reviews (29)
Q&A (5)
Media (6)
Leave a Review
Faith F.
Sacramento , CA
82 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
I received this pack for Christmas last year and I'm barely having to buy the full-size now. You get so much for your money and mascara lasts so long. My favorite out of all of these miniature ones is they're real. My mom loves the roller lash. All of these mascaras are so beautifully made and the formulas are awesome. If you're looking to buy a new mascara but don't know which one to get I would definitely get this first to see which ones you love before buying the full-size and all the other ones you can give us gifts if you wanted to
Kristy C.
Abington, PA
365 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 5
This set would be better if the push up liner was left out completely. It is very difficult to work with and very dry/clumpy. Roller Lash is something i use everyday, it's lengthening and the only mascara that curls on it's own. The tinted lash primer works great alone for a natural look or as a primer. They're real was my #! until Roller Lash launched, Now I layer them for extra drama. Bag Gal is very voluming. In my opinion, Benefit has the best mascaras hands down. This is a great set to figure out which one works best for you because they are all different.
Ashley S.
74 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
Got it on sale for $18.00. Great price and bargain for 4 mascaras and a eyeliner. Badgal lash mascara and other mascara gave me great volume and separates lashes without need for primer. The They're Real mascara doesn't separate as well as the Badgal mascara though. The eyeliner is SUPER pigmented. Sometimes clumps and skips if you're not careful but still great.
Amanda E.
Wilmington, NC
87 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 1
I actually bought my first thing of mascara just to "spend ___ dollars and get a free bag" situation.  I hadn't planned on much with it.  I ended up LOVING it and when it is out, I will be buying more.  I love the wand, it makes me look like I actually have lashes!  The price is pretty "normal" for mascara these days. 
Italy E.
Slinger, WI
27 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
They're real mascara is the business! My curly lashes get so elongated from this product I rarely wear lashes anymore! I bought the travel size tube, big mistake. Get the big one the first time around because you'll love it! Can't wait to try more Benefit Cosmetics products.
Hunter B.
93 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 2
I’ve been getting samples of these and they’re amazing. I’d love to get these for a gift for my friend whose into making makeup beauty tutorials for YouTube. It seems the sets are for affordable and younger multiple different types !!
Yuli V.
Pacoima, CA
95 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 3
Let me just start by telling you that benefit does not play when it comes to mascara ! Ohh my god! I use these products every day and they slay my life (no kidding) so I do recommend these to other people
Adyson L.
18 reviews
Got this as a gift for Christmas. Great arrange of products. Small sample sizes but they give you a test to see if you want to keep using and you definitely will want to. Love the selection
Samantha C.
2 reviews
I love all of this mascaras. They work wonders. My favorite of the bunch is they are real. I bought this product at Sephora. It was affordable. You get a variety of products to test out. I recommend this product.
Jacquelyn C.
Hendersonvlle, TN
369 reviews
Beauty Junkie Expert Level 4
Love this mini versions of the mascaras from benefit. I am able to compare how they apply and longevity. I personally like the they're real line. It's been tried and tested for me. my second favorite is the push up mascara. This set is a good way to test the products without spending a lot for each of them.
Shelby G.
39 reviews
What is the difference between all of these? Are any clumpier thab others? Do any give a more "falsies" look? Is one more natural-looking than another?
Destinee C.
Nampa, ID
4 reviews
Can someone give any insight on which mascara they prefer the most? I feel like a find one I really like and then it stops working as great!
Samantha H.
377 reviews
What's the difference between these mascaras? I haven't used this brand yet and have been very curious to try but they can be pricey so before I buy any feed back
Avery P.
Vernon, BC
15 reviews
Does Benefit do animal testing on their products?
Cassie P.
St, NL
74 reviews
Need this in my love!!  

You came for the review, stay for the community. Over 25 million honest reviews from people like you.

Sign up now